No sector-by-sector Brexit impact assessments exist, David Davis tells MPs

Britain’s opposition Labour Party Shadow Brexit Secretary Keir Starmer

In a sometimes gruelling appearance before the Brexit select committee Davis said there had been "no systematic impact assessment" of leaving the European Union, having talked previously about such apparent studies existing "in excruciating detail".Davis insisted he had been misunderstood, saying the only work undertaken comprised broad surveys of various parts of the economy, none of which included any forecasts of how Brexit might affect them.

Davis also said government plans for the possibility of leaving the European Union without a trade deal did not include any impact assessment.

Ten Conservative MPs and one DUP MP voted that Davis was not in contempt of parliament, hours after the Brexit secretary said that there had been "no systematic impact assessment" of leaving the EU.

"There's no systematic impact assessment I'm aware of", Davis told a parliamentary committee, saying it would be more appropriate to conduct such analysis later in the negotiating process.

He said: "Whoever is demanding that these reports are shown and given the light of day deserve to be lied to because they're just playing games to stop Brexit".

Despite Davis's claims regarding the usefulness of such analysis, the Irish Government has been carrying out impact assessments since the 2016 referendum on leaving the EU.

Instead the government handed over instead 850 pages of heavily-edited "sectoral analyses" setting out detail about the current position of different parts of the economy.

"We will at some stage do the best we can to quantify the effect of different negotiating outcomes as we come up to them - bearing in mind we haven't started phase two (negotiations) yet", Davis said, referring to the second phase of talks which will focus on trade.


And he told Mr Benn there was no "formal quantitative" assessment undertaken of the likely impact of leaving the customs union before the Government committed itself to the step.

'It is unbelievable that these long-trumpeted impact assessments don't even exist, meaning the government has no idea what their Brexit plans will do to the country'.

But the agreement was scuttled at the last minute when the Democratic Unionist Party, which props up Prime Minister Theresa May's minority government, warned it wouldn't support a deal it saw as undermining Northern Ireland's place in the United Kingdom.

"Do not draw the conclusion that because you use the word impact, you have written an impact assessment", he said.

Opposition MPs have pressured the government into releasing a summary of its analysis to the committee.

A Labour member of the Brexit committee, Seema Malhotra, described the failure to make assessments as "a dereliction of duty". Either way, how is Davis still in his job?'

Lammy has since contacted Commons Speaker John Bercow to seek advice on beginning contempt proceedings against Davis and other ministers he believes have misled Parliament about the existence and nature of the Brexit impact studies.

Related News:



Most liked

Never represented Sunni Waqf Board in Supreme Court: Kapil Sibal
I do not know on whose behalf the counsel for the Muslims appearing in the apex court, Kapil Sibal had stated this. It said it had not issued any instruction to Sibal to seek shifting of hearing till after the general elections.

As Fires Spread Across Los Angeles, Museums and Galleries Close
Padilla said she was woken up at approximately 4 a.m.by the Los Angeles County Fire Department's orders to evacuate immediately. Some area restaurants chose to remain open amid the fire and smoke-filled skies, while others closed shop for the day.

Earnings Analysis Of Kinder Morgan, Inc. (KMI)
Colony Group Llc increased Ishares S&P 500 Growth Index (IVW) stake by 5,678 shares to 51,559 valued at $7.06 million in 2017Q2. Associated Banc-Corp increased Vanguard Tax Managed Intl Fd (VEA) stake by 10,688 shares to 84,591 valued at $3.50M in 2017Q2.

Health Dept investigating source of listeriosis outbreak
Motsoaledi says newborns, the elderly, pregnant women and people with weak immunity are at high risk of getting listeriosis . This can lead to septicaemia and meningoencephalitis‚ which is an infection of the brain.

SpaceX's new "Falcon Heavy" rocket to carry Tesla Roadster to Mars
The rocket, which uses 27 Merlin engines (in three blocks of 9 engines), will generate 5 million pounds of thrust. The answer is somewhere between the second and third options, according to Musk and anonymous SpaceX sources.

Cineworld Agrees To Buy Regal Entertainment For $3.6 Bln
Shares repurchase programs are generally a sign that the company's board believes its shares are undervalued. Alliancebernstein L.P. raised its stake in Regal Entertainment Group by 11.6% during the 2nd quarter.

Apple To Be Charged $15 Billion As Back Tax By Ireland
KitGuru Says: Apple may start setting the money for this aside soon, but it seems clear that it still wants to get out of it. According to the EU, the tax deal allowed Apple to pay nearly nothing in tax on its European profits between 2003 and 2014.

Willie Taggart coming back to Florida to coach FSU
McMurphy also cited sources saying returning to his home state of Florida was a factor in Taggart's decision. Despite stabilizing a handful couple of programs, FSU's next head coach boasts a 47-50 overall record.

Baker Mayfield named Heisman Trophy finalist
He averaged 10.5 yards per carry and 114.3 yards per game on the ground and finished his high school career with 83 touchdowns. Mayfield is considered the favorite to win the award this year, despite some off-field issues that have clouded his candidacy.

Russian Federation banned from 2018 Winter Olympics over doping
Those with histories of rigorous drug testing may petition for permission to compete in neutral uniforms. Bach also said the Russian committee must give the IOC $15 million to pay for the doping investigation.

'House of Cards' to finish final season without Kevin Spacey
Spacey reportedly traveled to Arizona last month to seek unspecified treatment at a rehabilitation facility. Here's to Robin Wright getting even more screen time in the final year of House of Cards .





Most Commented