Trump's good idea on Medicaid reform: Honchariw

Adam Berry  Getty Images

However, because the administration is legally bound to justify the change as furthering the goals of the low-income medical insurance program, Medicaid's top bureaucrat, Seema Verma, has argued that the requirement will improve health, based on evidence that richer people tend to be healthier.

The change will allow states to craft programs that would require Medicaid recipients to prove they are working, training for a job, or volunteering in their communities, according to guidance issued by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

Wolf vetoed a budget-related bill a year ago that would have required the administration to include a work-search requirement in the Medicaid program.

In a letter to state Medicaid directors, the White House is signaling a willingness to approve state requests to require people seeking health coverage through the Medicaid program to have a job or participate in other approved forms of "community engagement".

The work requirement does not affect pregnant women, the elderly, the disabled, and, of course, children.

CMS says that states should "consider" not imposing work requirements on groups including caregivers, people with health problems, or full-time students. The addition of a work requirement moves us further away from the idea of health care as a right and towards an America that does not provide a safety net for the most vulnerable, including people with disabilities.

Soon, the administration will likely approve "waiver" proposals, starting with Kentucky and IN and followed by other states, to end Medicaid coverage not only for people who aren't working, but also for those who didn't pay premiums - or renew their coverage - on time.

Kentucky, where the uninsured rate for low-income adults plummeted under the Medicaid expansion (from almost 40% in 2013 to 7% at the end of 2016), estimates its proposed changes will cut enrollment by 15% in five years. They generally work in low-wage or minimum-wage jobs that offer either unaffordable health insurance or none at all.


It's more common for Medicaid enrollees to hold jobs if they live in states that expanded Medicaid under Obamacare. By that time their health care will be much more expensive to the state (if they survive that long).

In Massachusetts, employers are facing a shortage of workers in a low unemployment economy and state officials are struggling to cover the cost of growing Medicaid enrollment in the face of threatened cuts in federal health care spending.

He also believes the work requirement may be financially counter productive.

Opponents of the move quickly decried the Trump administration's action, arguing that it represented a gutting of Medicaid and the administration's disregard for the poor (which was a big part of the pushback against the failed effort to replace Obamacare). While the provision is itself regressive, funneling money into the pockets of the private insurance companies, the result will be more people losing their insurance and premiums skyrocketing for those who maintain it. Similarly, 60 percent of Nevadans who gained Medicaid coverage via the ACA expansion didn't work at all during 2015.

The new policy would not apply to people who qualify for the program because of a disability, the memo said. These able-bodied men and women are the ones who will be required to find work in order to keep their Medicaid benefits.

All the policy will do, Berg said, is increase bureaucracy and paperwork, "supposedly from the small government people", because it will force working people to leave work, or those on a job search to stop searching and have to go to a government office to fill out a form to show they are working or searching for a job. Calling the new policy "unconscionable and illegal", Eliot Fishman, senior health policy director at the liberal consumer health lobby Families USA, said in a statement: "Today's announcement isn't about work". No state or federal administrator can add another requirement that is not in federal law. That represents about 15 million people.

Federal Medicaid officials compared a work requirement to similar conditions in other programs like food stamps, now known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, and the welfare program known as Temporary Assistance for Needy Families.

"It's basically creating layers of government, confusion, bureaucracy that doesn't need to be there for people who are probably working anyway", she said. Additionally, the guidance details that states can not accrue savings from loss in enrollment due to work requirements, which means that states will need to pay for any work requirement administrative burden, such as determining if an individual is working, developing an enrollee reporting system and employment supportive services, etc. If I were reliant on Medicaid in a state with a work requirement, I would have had to pay for years of testing and doctor appointments myself before I finding a doctor willing to sign off on a work exemption.

Related News:

  • India ruin S.Africa's progress with run outs as Amla falls

    India ruin S.Africa's progress with run outs as Amla falls

    Amla survived a chance down the legside off Ishant Sharma with Patel getting both gloves to the ball but spilling the chance. Their bowlers took 20 wickets, but the only part when we were a little bit better was we got more runs in the first innings.
    Wall Street surges as consumer and bank stocks gain

    Wall Street surges as consumer and bank stocks gain

    Benchmark U.S. crude rose 23 cents to settle at $63.80 a barrel; earlier in the day, they climbed as high as $64.77. The company also said, however, that it would close dozens of Sam's Club locations in the coming months.

    Determining the stand-point of: Applied Materials, Inc. (AMAT)

    It increased, as 52 investors sold AAPL shares while 1034 reduced holdings. 88 funds opened positions while 466 raised stakes. Norinchukin Bank The increased Disney Walt Co (NYSE:DIS) stake by 34,150 shares to 453,559 valued at $44.71M in 2017Q3.
  • El-Zakzaky's Health Remains Stable, DSS Insists

    El-Zakzaky's Health Remains Stable, DSS Insists

    Before I used to be examined by security doctors, this time I did not agree, and my own doctors came to examine me. "I'm getting better", he said.
    Yuvraj Singh, Gautam Gambhir, Chris Gayle, among 1122 registered for IPL Auction

    Yuvraj Singh, Gautam Gambhir, Chris Gayle, among 1122 registered for IPL Auction

    The player registration closed on Friday and 1122 players have signed up for the auction that will be held on January 27 and 28. Surprisingly, two players from United States of America and one player from Scotland have also registered for the IPL auction.
    Iran says nuclear deal with major powers not renegotiable

    Iran says nuclear deal with major powers not renegotiable

    Also addressing reporters, French Minister Jean-Yves Le Drian called the deal "essential", saying: "There is no alternative". Also on January 8, another Iranian official, this time atomic chief Ali Akbar Salehi , issued a warning.
  • Shazam Movie Set for April 5, 2019 Release

    Shazam Movie Set for April 5, 2019 Release

    It's like Superman meets Big , and that's just so fun. "It's not glum, and like, 'Oh, I have to save the world again'". The upcoming film is set to star Asher Angel as Billy Batson and Zachary Levi as Shazam (formerly Captain Marvel).
    Friday morning I-95 crashes snarl traffic in and around St

    Friday morning I-95 crashes snarl traffic in and around St

    Johns County roadways this year according to information available from the Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles. The Tennessee Highway Patrol is on the scene of a fatal crash in Marshall County.
    Media figures label Trump racist after immigration remarks

    Media figures label Trump racist after immigration remarks

    The White House has not denied the language, nor have the several Republican lawmakers in the meeting. Donald Trump has backtracked on his denial that he described some African nations as "shitholes ".
  • Students versus masters: Raptors ready to take fast pace to Warriors

    Still, the Cavs reportedly view him as an asset they can move "in the right deal" before the NBA's February 8th trade deadline. It was an unexpected blowout considering the Raptors were missing an injured Kyle Lowry and a suspended Serge Ibaka .
    Trump says US-Norway ties 'robust'

    Trump says US-Norway ties 'robust'

    Moreover, the agreement hurt United States businesses overall and gave advantages to other countries such as China, Trump added. We're not gonna let that happen.

    What Do Analysts Say About Endo International plc (ENDP)

    Pub Employees Retirement System Of Ohio invested in 0.38% or 40,223 shares. 42 funds opened positions while 136 raised stakes. Airain ltd purchased a new position in shares of Endo International during the 2nd quarter valued at about $387,000.


Most liked

Democrats want to interview Ivanka Trump in Russian Federation investigation
Two Trump campaign aides - including campaign manager Paul Manafort - have been indicted in the investigation. That has angered Democrats, who say those probes are distractions from the Russian Federation investigations.

Oregon State Beavers Articles, Photos, and Videos
Arizona trailed 27-26 at halftime, but the Wildcats missed their first 12 shots and had five turnovers to open the third quarter. Arizona's Keanu Pinder did not play against Oregon State, but gave the Wildcats a boost of energy off the bench against Oregon.

Heyman | Astros acquire Gerrit Cole from Pirates
Cole's ERA was 3.88 in 2016 and 4.26 last year, the two highest marks of his career for the 26-year-old right-hander. Musgrove did appear in 38 games for the Astros last season, posting a 4.77 ERA with 98 strikeouts in 109.1 innings.

Comcast (NASDAQ:CMCSA) Earns Daily Coverage Optimism Rating of 0.18
Addenda Capital Inc decreased Danaher Corp Del (NYSE:DHR) stake by 13,822 shares to 50,365 valued at $4.33M in 2017Q3. Marshall Wace Llp owns 0.08% invested in KeyCorp (NYSE:KEY) for 95,441 shares. (NYSE:ROL) for 1.28 million shares.

Accenture Plc (ACN) Receives Average Recommendation of "Buy" from Analysts
The information technology services provider reported $1.79 EPS for the quarter, beating the consensus estimate of $1.67 by $0.12. Laurion Capital Limited Partnership reported 0% of its portfolio in Accenture plc (NYSE:ACN). 61,511 are owned by Mcrae Cap.

England To Play Nigeria And Costa Rica Ahead Of World Cup
England is a very strong team presently and I believe they will give us a very good match. Akinwunmi who is also the chairman of the federation's Organizing Committee said.

Abouth 300 Palestinians injured in renewed clashes with Israeli forces
Tensions were already high ahead of Friday's protests after two 16-year-old Palestinians were killed in clashes with the IDF on Thursday.

Has $1110599000 Position in Fidelity National Information Services, Inc. (FIS)
United Services Automobile Association holds 0.05% of its portfolio in Fidelity National Information Services, Inc . (NYSE:FIS). Pilgrims Pride had 20 analyst reports since October 30, 2015 according to SRatingsIntel. (NYSE: FIS ) for 704,465 shares.

Microsoft Corporation (MSFT), Scripps Networks Interactive, Inc. (SNI)
Also, it has an estimated price-earnings (P/E) multiple of 15.73 and a trailing 12-month price-earnings (P/E) multiple of 14.63. Farmers & Merchants Invests invested 0% of its portfolio in Scripps Networks Interactive, Inc. (NASDAQ:SNI) for 41,200 shares.

Anti-Time Warner Inc Institutional Investors Sentiment Runs Low in Q3 2017
The institutional investors in our partner's database reported: 586.69 million shares, down from 600.08 million shares in 2017Q2. Front Barnett Associate Ltd Limited Liability Company has invested 0.04% of its portfolio in Time Warner Inc. (NYSE:TWX).

Iran Says US Is 'Maliciously Violating' Nuclear Deal By Demanding Changes
Meanwhile, the Trump administration is imposing new targeted sanctions on Iran that aren't part of this deal. Work already has begun on this front, the official said.

Sheryl Sandberg, Jack Dorsey Won't Seek Re-Election to Disney Board
Both Sandberg and Dorsey are not standing for re-election due to conflicts relating to matters before the board, Disney said. The entertainment giant named two members to its board in December, tapping CEOs from the software and biotech industries.

Trump in 'excellent health': WH on 1st medical examination of President
In an Oval Office meeting, Trump questioned why the USA should admit immigrants from Haiti and "shithole countries" in Africa. I've never seen a statement like this by African countries directed at the United States".

African countries demand Trump's apology over 'racial' slur
President Nana Addo's comments came hours after former President Mahama described President Trump as racist for his remarks. Trump said during a bipartisan meeting on immigration earlier this week, according to multiple people in the room.

Clouds lift as North Korea boosts Pyeongchang Olympics
However, President Trump appears to have won the war of words, after North and South Korea held rare formal talks Wednesday. This decision may have been the key element in the North's agreement to meet with the South.