Gorsuch Rejects Deportation Mandate for Legal Immigrant Convict

Gorsuch Rejects Deportation Mandate for Legal Immigrant Convict

President Trump's Supreme Court pick has largely sided with the conservative members of the bench since his appointment, but sided with the liberal wing on Tuesday.

The court upheld a 2015 lower court ruling that the Immigration and Nationality Act provision requiring Dimaya's deportation created uncertainty over which crimes may be considered violent, risking arbitrary enforcement in violation of the U.S. Constitution.

James Garcia Dimaya, a native of the Philippines, was admitted to the United States in 1992 when he was 13 as a lawful permanent resident.

In 2010, the government sought to deport Dimaya. An immigration judge determined that Dimaya was removable from the U.S. because of his two state court convictions.

The government argued among other things that he could be removed from the country because his convictions qualified as crimes of violence that allowed his removal under immigration law.


In court, arguing for the Trump administration, Deputy Solicitor General Edwin Kneedler said that when it comes to deportation, "I think it is important for the court to understand that immigration provisions and grounds for deportation are often written in very broad and general terms and given content by the executive branch in which Congress has vested authority". Conviction for a crime of violence makes deportation "a virtual certainty" for an immigrant, no matter how long he has lived in the United States, Justice Elena Kagan wrote in her opinion for the court.

In this case, President Barack Obama's administration took the same position in the Supreme Court in defense of the challenged provision.

The law, although covering crimes that include actual violence, attempted violence or a threat of violence, goes on to add in crimes that involve "a substantial risk that physical force against the person or property of another".

A federal appeals court in San Francisco previously struck down the provision as too vague, and on Monday the Supreme Court agreed. The Supreme Court affirmed that ruling Tuesday.

The case, Sessions v Dimaya, was initially argued in January of 2017 by a court that was short a member because the late Justice Antonin Scalia's seat had not yet been filled.

Related News:

  • International Monetary Fund maintains 3-pct growth forecast for S. Korea

    However, the forecast for the next year worsened - down to 3.3 percent. Its decision-making also reflects members' relative influence. That's in line with its most recent estimate in January.
    China's GDP grows 6.8% in first quarter, more than expected

    China's GDP grows 6.8% in first quarter, more than expected

    Analysts say the main risk to China's economy is now centred on the escalating trade dispute with the United States. They also say exports to Europe, the USA and Southeast Asia increased.
    There's a mess of new content coming soon to Sea of Thieves

    There's a mess of new content coming soon to Sea of Thieves

    It's good that the developers have recognised and addressed this, meaning that more content could help Sea of Thieves' longevity. Beyond that, five more content updates are planned for the rest of 2018, but only two have been revealed so far.
  • Scathing Comey interview provokes President Trump

    Scathing Comey interview provokes President Trump

    There is no proof, however, that Bill Clinton offered Lynch a job or a favor to ease off the investigation into his wife. Mr Comey is embarking on a public rollout of his book, A Higher Loyalty , which comes out on Tuesday.
    Video Shows Police Beating Naked, Black Harvard Student

    Video Shows Police Beating Naked, Black Harvard Student

    He has been charged with indecent exposure, disorderly conduct, assault, resisting arrest, and battery on ambulance personnel. Ohene was reportedly violent and an officer punched him five times in the stomach to calm him down and arrest him.
    Syria war: Trump says missiles 'will be coming'

    Syria war: Trump says missiles 'will be coming'

    Prime Minister Theresa May held a special cabinet meeting to weigh whether Britain should join in any possible military action. Earlier, Russian officials said some missiles were intercepted by the Soviet-made antimissile batteries used by Syrian forces.
  • Cathy Yan Will Direct Margot Robbie in HARLEY QUINN Film

    Cathy Yan Will Direct Margot Robbie in HARLEY QUINN Film

    Robbie's LuckyChap is producing with Sue Kroll and her Kroll & Co Entertainment, along with Bryan Unkeless of Clubhouse Pictures. Cathy Yan is in line to direct DC Films' Harley Quinn/Birds of Prey movie, according to Deadline .
    Supreme Court not in favour of handing over Kathua case to CBI

    Supreme Court not in favour of handing over Kathua case to CBI

    Senior Counsel Indira Jaising, representing the girl's father, said the situation in Jammu was not fit for a free and fair trial. The minor was kept sedated and sexually assaulted once again before she was bludgeoned to death, revealed the chargesheet.
    Syria says false alarm set off its air defences

    Syria says false alarm set off its air defences

    The reports claimed that 6 missiles targeted the Shayrat airbase in the central province of Homs, but a lot of them were intercepted by Syrian air defenses.
  • National Basketball Association playoffs are wide open _ for once

    In the eastern conference, there is the Cleveland Cavaliers , the Toronto Raptors , and the steaming hot Philadelphia 76ers . In the off-season they added a future Hall-of-Famer in Carmelo Anthony and one of the top two-way players in Paul George.
    Folau escapes RA sanction over controversial comments

    Folau escapes RA sanction over controversial comments

    But Jesus told us that when you stand up for Him in this world, you can expect backlash. We accept Israel's position ", Castle said in a statement on Tuesday.
    Tiger Roll wins 2018 Grand National in dramatic finish at Aintree

    Tiger Roll wins 2018 Grand National in dramatic finish at Aintree

    Coming in fifth place on Milansbar, Bryony Frost had an excellent showing in her first-ever ride at the Grand National. All the way up the run-in I thought he wasn't going to get there and then right on the line I thought we had a shout.


Most liked

Rays OF to undergo surgery on thumb
Kiermaier was injured Sunday while sliding head first into second base in a 10-4 loss to the Philadelphia Phillies . Kiermaier was undergoing an MRI this morning and the Rays should know more before tonight's game against Texas.

Fifth Third Bank's (FITB) "Buy" Rating Reaffirmed at Vining Sparks
Commonwealth Bank Of Australia decreased Metlife Inc (NYSE:MET) stake by 6,804 shares to 257,972 valued at $13.04M in 2017Q4. Clear Harbor Asset Ltd Liability Corporation invested 0.06% of its portfolio in Fifth Third Bancorp ( NASDAQ : FITB ).

FA Charges Chelsea's Alonso With Violent Conduct
Chelsea defender Marcos Alonso has been charged retrospectively by the Football Association for a unsafe tackle on Southampton forward Shane Long on Saturday.

Domino's Pizza, Inc. (DPZ) Surges to All-Time High
Total analysts of 17 have positions in Domino's Pizza (NYSE:DPZ) as follows: 11 rated it a "Buy", 0 with "Sell" and 6 with "Hold". Domino's Pizza, Inc. registered $3.83 million net activity with 0 insider buys and 2 selling transactions since October 17, 2017.

Stormy Daniels says she is 'done being bullied'
This artist's drawing purportedly shows the man that the adult film actress Stormy Daniels says threatened her in a Las Vegas parking lot in 2011.

India's Closing Flag Bearer Mary Kom Delighted With Boxing Performance
It is true that Mary Kom has had to take a break in boxing when she got married and gave birth to three children. Her reply, though, left the entire audience in titters. "I will continue to play as long as I want", she said.

Google's AR-powered microscope can help in real-time cancer detection
Though the new kits cost more, they are worth the price, as they come with all the needed items to do it yourself (DIY). For numerous sites, Google has developed 3D models that allow viewers to see these cultural wonders from every angle.

Baboons use barrel to escape Texas research Center, officials say
But, perhaps foolishly, the institute gave them 55-gallon barrels as "enrichment" tools "used to help mimic foraging behaviors". The 4 critters escaped from the Southwest National Primate Research Center at approximately 3:15 p.m.

Research Ratings: Commerce Bancshares, Inc. (CBSH), Melco Resorts & Entertainment Limited (MLCO)
Technical analysis of Melco Resorts & Entertainment Limited ( MLCO ) stock includes study of technical indicators and past trends. In Play Stocks are volatile enough to produce good risk and reward trading opportunities for both bull and bear traders intraday.

Animal rights group slam bear use at Russian soccer match
The Russian football league has been criticised after a trained bear was forced to perform tricks before a third division game. In a widely circulated video, the bear is seen standing on his hind legs while clapping to fans.

Man City cleared over Garre transfer
A formal announcement from CAS is expected later this week, while Velez could yet make a technical appeal against CAS's decision. Velez claim City acted unethically by approaching Garre when he was just 15, before signing him days after his 16th birthday.

Kendrick Lamar Wins Pulitzer Prize for 'Damn' Album
Explanatory Reporting: Jointly awarded to the staffs of the Arizona Republic and the USA Today Network . The Pulitzer board called the album a work that captures the complexity of African-American life.

Atlantic City's Tropicana To Remain Open After Icahn's $1.85 Billion Deal
This purchase does not affect the Tropicana in Las Vegas, which is owned and operated by a different company. Eldorado is acquiring the operating assets of seven casinos in six states, including two in Nevada.

Assad calls Syria air strikes act of 'American aggression'
Haley, in her Fox News interview, also defended its use as a military term, rather than as a broader political statement. The strikes came around one week after the chemical attack on civilians in the rebel-held town of Douma on April 7th.

Students arrested for stalking Smriti Irani
The four men, who are students of the Ram Lal College, were drunk when they started following Irani's vehicle in Delhi's Lutyens. The four accused have been booked for stalking, criminal intimidation and intention to insult modesty of a woman.