Supreme Court sides with officer in Arizona police shooting case

Jeffrey Lee

Anxious that Hughes was threatening Chadwick, one officer, Andrew Kisela, shot her four times through a chain-link fence. Two other officers were on hand with their weapons drawn, but thought talking was better than shooting in the circumstances. But Kisela then fired four shots, striking Hughes.

In affidavits, Chadwick later said that Hughes appeared non-threatening and that she did not understand what was happening when the officers ordered her to drop the knife, as she was on medication for bipolar disorder.

All that makes for an interesting test case of the thorny rules governing police officer liability for deadly force. But the courts ruled that was an illegal endorsement of religion. In recent years, it has been repeatedly invoked by the Supreme Court to quash litigation brought against police officers accused of using excessive force. Kisela had responded to reports that Hughes was in the street with a large knife "screaming and crying very loud"; when he arrived, he saw Hughes approaching another woman. To the rest, Kisela was too hasty in a situation where no one was in immediate danger and two colleagues who also had their guns drawn were convinced that more talking was worthwhile. "This contributes significantly to the difficulties in holding police accountable", he said. "For even assuming a Fourth Amendment violation occurred-a proposition that is not at all evident-on these facts Kisela was at least entitled to qualified immunity". "But the federal courts can not exercise jurisdiction in a civil case beyond the limits prescribed by the due process clause of the Constitution, no matter how horrendous the underlying attacks or morally compelling the plaintiff's claims". When she began to walk toward Sharon Chadwick, police yelled for her to drop the knife.

In her dissent, Sotomayor noted that Kisela was the only officer on the scene who used deadly force, and that he did so without warning that he would open fire.


If all this sounds like a fancily worded version of a Reddit argument about any given high-profile police killing from the past few years, that's because it basically is.

The Supreme Court rejected a similar appeal in 2014 when it refused to hear arguments from thousands of victims of the September 11, 2001, attacks on the US, who sought to sue Middle Eastern companies and people for allegedly providing support to al-Qaeda. "It does so based on a legal doctrine - qualified immunity - that the Supreme Court invented out of whole cloth to help create a policy of near-zero accountability for law enforcement". The jury recommended a sentence of life without the possibility of parole by a vote of seven to five, but the judge overrode that reccomendation and sentenced Lee to death. But at a minimum, Sotomayor added, there is enough dispute about the facts and the law in Kisela's case that the court should not have reversed without the benefit of briefing or oral argument on the merits.

But the majority of Chief Justice John Roberts' court is systematically biased in favor of police, in Sotomayor's view, and thus too quick to swing the ax in favor of officers.

Related News:

  • CWG 2018: Indian boxers cleared of doping charges

    CWG 2018: Indian boxers cleared of doping charges

    However, CGF chief executive David Grevemberg has said it is a "clear breach" of the No-Needle Policy. The Commonwealth Games 2018 opening ceremony will take place on Wednesday, April 4, 2018.
    Police need help identifying armed robbery suspect

    Police need help identifying armed robbery suspect

    When police attempted to arrest the woman, the man she was with assaulted the two officers and took off. A third party identified Bourque to police, describing him as "someone he had known most of his life".
    Man injured in officer-involved shooting in Zebulon

    Man injured in officer-involved shooting in Zebulon

    The officer then dropped the taser and pulled out his service weapon and fired multiple rounds, striking the suspect, Pfohl said. One of the officers, later identified as Officer Adam Arena, fired several shots in self-defense, hitting the man in both legs.
  • Average Michigan gas prices drop 2 cents

    Average Michigan gas prices drop 2 cents

    AAA says Florida gas prices increased almost 10 cents during the past week, but leveled off over the weekend. Gas prices statewide have declined by about 2 cents per gallon in the past week, AAA Michigan said.
    Cauvery issue: TN CM, Dy CM lead hunger strike called by AIADMK

    Cauvery issue: TN CM, Dy CM lead hunger strike called by AIADMK

    Moreover, over 21 lakh shops will remain shut today in the state after a bandh call by trade unions AITUC, CITU, LPF and INTUC. The protest that began at 8 a.m., will conclude at 5 p.m.

    Russian Federation asks chemical weapons agency for answers

    After the phone call , Washington expelled 60 Russian diplomats and shut down a Russian consulate in Seattle. Russian Federation has said it "insists" on seeing Ms Skripal after her condition dramatically improved.
  • Family killed after refusing to marry minor daughter to married man

    Family killed after refusing to marry minor daughter to married man

    They rushed to the house to find 7-year-old Jermon Perry lying semi-conscious with a gunshot wound to the head, KDSK reported . Family friend Max Ribner last week took issue with the notion it was something other than a tragic accident.
    Dean Elgar produces sensational catch on day three vs Australia

    Dean Elgar produces sensational catch on day three vs Australia

    Cricket experts and fans were in outrage on Monday night as South Africa built their second innings lead to over 600 runs. They shared a fourth-wicket partnership of 170, the best for any wicket by either side during the series.
    Walmart Inc. (NYSE:WMT)

    Walmart Inc. (NYSE:WMT)

    It improved, as 51 investors sold LYB shares while 271 reduced holdings. 104 funds opened positions while 254 raised stakes. Wagner Bowman Corporation owns 1,350 shares. (NYSE:PX). 113,000 were accumulated by Cincinnati Financial Corp. (NYSE:LM).
  • BCCI bars Smith, Warner from IPL

    BCCI bars Smith, Warner from IPL

    Internet giants Google , meanwhile, could bid for digital rights alone post a backend agreement with a mobile network company. BCCI on 28 March 2018 banned Smith and Warner from this year's IPL .
    Siddaramaiah challenges Yeddyurappa to contest from Varuna instead of fielding son

    Siddaramaiah challenges Yeddyurappa to contest from Varuna instead of fielding son

    The Election Commission on Tuesday announced that Assembly polls would be held on May 12 for 224 seats and the votes will be counted on May 15 .

    U.S. stocks tumble, led by tech pullback and trade fears

    Stocks are falling sharply on Wall Street after China raised import duties on US pork, apples and other products. Other market leaders like industrial giant Boeing and streaming video service Netflix also slumped.


Most liked

Smith has to be respected as a player, says Ajinkya Rahane
Rajasthan Royals are slated to begin their IPL campaign against Sunrisers Hyderabad in the opening match on April 9. Having found Steve Smith involved in the incident of ball-tampering, Cricket Australia put a one-year ban on him.

Erdogan threatens Kosovo's PM, says Haradinaj will pay a price
Ankara alleged the six men were members of US-based Turkish Muslim cleric Fethullah Gulen's Islamic movement. At its peak, the Gulen movement operated schools in 160 countries from Afghanistan to the United States.

Israel suspends deal on resettling African migrants
Tens of thousands crossed the porous desert border before Israel completed a barrier in 2012 that stopped the influx. The new deal would be implemented in three stages over five years, said Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office.

London murder rate overtakes NY for first time as crime surges
Scotland Yard said it was called to reports of gunfire in Markhouse Road in Walthamstow at around 10pm. Separately, in Walthamstow, a 16-year-old boy was found suffering from gunshot injuries.

China's Defunct Space Station Meets A Fiery End Over The South Pacific
Researchers had been closely monitoring the Tiangong-1 for months as Earth's gravity pulled it lower and lower in its orbit. The massive 420-tonne International Space Station is also expected to crash down at Point Nemo in 2024.

Oklahoma schools shut down as thousands of teachers strike
Students sat outside in the cold on metal chairs as they talked with each other and their teachers about the essay prompts . Gabby Davis, a senior, called on the Legislature to realize that protesters were not just calling for a teacher pay raise.

Avengers: Infinity War Directors Tease Scary Title for Avengers 4
We really don't know anything about Avengers 4 , but some insane rumors about the story are already circulating. Avengers: Infinity War opens on April 27th 2018 and will feature an all-star cast including Robert Downey Jr .

LDS church replaces visiting teaching and home teaching with "ministering"
State Department and the Washington, D.C. -based Center for Strategic and International Studies before becoming a church leader. The rules changed, the church said, when top leaders prayed and received a revelation that everyone deserved inclusion.

No chance! Heynckes tells Real Madrid to forget Lewandowski
Real Madrid are well aware of Bayern's intentions and the player is reportedly happy to make a permanent move to Germany. Bayern have scored 21 goals in eight games in the competition this season, eight against Besiktas in the round of 16.

Macron: AI could threaten democracy
It is expected to be the biggest wave of industrial unrest since Mr Macron's election last May. "That's a competition issue".

Dividend Stock With Analysts Upside: NextEra Energy Partners, LP (NYSE:NEP)
The firm has "Overweight" rating given on Thursday, March 8 by Morgan Stanley. ( NYSE :NEE) on Monday, October 16 to "Buy" rating. After $0.74 actual EPS reported by Lowe's Companies, Inc. for the previous quarter, Wall Street now forecasts 75.68% EPS growth.

Afghan military bombs religious seminary, scores killed
Mohammad Radmanish, a spokesman for the Defense Ministry denied that the gathering had been for religious purposes. The district of Dasht-e-Archi is a Taliban stronghold that has often been the scene of heavy fighting .

Dashboard video shows Sacramento sheriff's vehicle hit protester
Shaun Hampton also said the vehicle "sustained scratches, dents, and a shattered rear window" caused by vandals in the crowd. At the corner, demonstrators chanted "the whole damn system is guilty as hell" as motorists honked their horns in support.

Blue pinwheels promote child abuse prevention in Smith Co
Kids and medical professionals are creating a pinwheel garden and display signs about how to stop child abuse . Those rocks were distributed all over Belton, Temple and Morgan's Point Resort.

Cosmic lens helps Hubble capture most distant star ever seen
In this case, a rare cosmic alignment naturally magnified the supergiant more than 2,000 times, allowing astronomers to see it. Gravitational lensing relies on good luck, but it makes stars much easier to spot, easily magnifying them about 50 times over.