Judge invalidates state aid-in-dying law; appeal window is narrow

The judge said California's right-to-die law was passed improperly

Under the law, lethal prescriptions may be given to adults who are able to make medical decisions if their attending physician and a consulting physician have diagnosed a terminal disease expected to end in death within six months. Before that, two doctors must have determined that the patient would die within six months and was mentally competent to choose death.

A Christian mother who was offered a lethal dose of suicide pills as alternative treatment for her terminal cancer a week after California's physician-assisted suicide law went into effect nearly two years ago, celebrated on Tuesday when a state judge overturned the law calling it unconstitutional.

Groups including the Life Legal Defense Foundation and the American Academy of Medical Ethics filed a lawsuit to overturn the law on the day it took effect.

Critics convinced Ottolia that while the state constitution permits the governor to issue proclamations to convene extraordinary legislative sessions, the Legislature is prohibited from enacting bills that are not the specific subject of the proclamation.

But the legislative push originally fell short amid opposition from oncologists, Catholic hospitals, clergy and disability rights groups, who argued that the policy was immoral and could have a detrimental impact on health care for the state's most vulnerable patients.

The judge had not yet issued a written ruling by deadline. The laws force doctors to harm their patients and can make patients feel pressured to commit suicide to cut costs for their families, critics counter.

In a Tuesday statement on Facebook, Packer expressed confidence that Judge Ottolia's ruling will stand.

Becerra claimed legislation passed during special sessions is presumed to be constitutional.


"That special session was called to address funding shortages caused by Medi-Cal", Larson said.

"I am so grateful that California's assisted suicide law was overturned today".

The initial legislative effort to pass an assisted suicide bill failed in committee during the 2015 regular season, following months of media attention to the case of Brittany Maynard, a 29-year-old woman with an aggressive brain tumor who moved from California to OR in order to take advantage of legal physician-assisted suicide there.

Her story incited more awareness for the Death With Dignity movement, which began in OR when a group of physicians helped pass the first statewide law that allowed for terminally ill patients to request drugs to end their lives.

A total of seven states - California, Colorado, Hawaii, Montana, Oregon, Vermont and Washington - as well as the District of Columbia have laws on the books legalizing medical aid in dying for terminally ill patients, terminology preferred by advocates to the phrase "physician-assisted suicide". The state attorney was given five days to file an emergency appeal before the ruling will take effect.

There was no immediate comment from California Attorney General Xavier Becerra's office, which has defended the law in court. "For too many, assisted suicide will be the only affordable "treatment" that is offered them", the mother, Stephanie Packer, 35, said.

Eggman said Brown would have known "what he intended with the breadth of the special session", which also included objectives to "improve the efficiency and the efficacy of the health care system", and he signed the law.

In his decision, The Desert Sun reported, Ottolia argued the doctor-assisted suicide bill "does not fall within the scope of access to health care services" and "is not a matter of health care funding".

Related News:

  • Ford Resuming Output of F-Series After Supplier Fire

    Ford Resuming Output of F-Series After Supplier Fire

    Ford has said its financial results for the second quarter will take a hit, though the exact cost remains to be seen. Dearborn-based Ford put together a team that refurbished and relocated tooling needed to make parts for the vehicles.
    VK Singh visits N Korea to discuss growth in peninsula

    VK Singh visits N Korea to discuss growth in peninsula

    Kim Yong Dae, Vice President of the Presidium of the Supreme People's Assembly, H.E. India had said then that its trade with North Korea was in any case "minimal".
    Kent State graduate's photos with AR-10 and cap go viral

    Kent State graduate's photos with AR-10 and cap go viral

    The photo of Kaitlin Bennett also showed her holding a graduation cap with the phrase "come and take it" written on it. She was with her family and her boyfriend Sunday, the day after she graduated, when the photo was taken, she said.
  • Panchayat poll violence: Centre asks Bengal govt to send another report

    Panchayat poll violence: Centre asks Bengal govt to send another report

    The state administration, however, claimed only six of those deaths were poll-related, State Election Commission (SEC) said. From the nomination stage to the day of polling, where was the spirit of democracy? "People were bullied", Modi said.
    Justify Odds-on Favorite at 7

    Justify Odds-on Favorite at 7

    The odds are against that, unless a bruised heel Justify was treated for acts up after training on an off track at Pimlico. Good Magic , which finished second in Kentucky, has the next-best odds of winning.
    In Pics: Bollywood Beauties Sizzle at Cannes 2018!

    In Pics: Bollywood Beauties Sizzle at Cannes 2018!

    The film, by Spike Lee, stars Corey Hawkins and Topher Grace and takes on the checkered history of the Ku Klux Klan. She slayed everyone on the red carpet at the 71st Cannes Film Festival as she flaunted her sexy figure.
  • Sherpa Kami Rita Sets Record with 22nd Successful Climb of Mount Everest

    Sherpa Kami Rita Sets Record with 22nd Successful Climb of Mount Everest

    While Lhakpa Sherpa was climbing to break her own record on Wednesday morning, other climbers were dealing with oxygen failures. On the Tibet side a team was forced to retreat from just below the summit when 11 of their bottled oxygen systems failed.
    Goldman Sachs Just Launched A New Cryptocurrency

    Goldman Sachs Just Launched A New Cryptocurrency

    We are excited to be working directly with Bitmain on realizing our shared vision. It recently got hold on cryptocurrency exchange is known as Poloniex.
    Florida teacher drowns 'nuisance animals' in front of class

    Florida teacher drowns 'nuisance animals' in front of class

    The mother of the student who shot the video, both who wish to remain anonymous, said to a reporter at WKMG-TV, "It made me sick. The cell phone video shows the raccoons in a cage being immersed in water in a trash can and drowning in front of the class.
  • Tickle Me, Fleury: Vegas goalie tickles Jets player's ear

    Tickle Me, Fleury: Vegas goalie tickles Jets player's ear

    After the game was tied 1-1, Vegas got two goals from its second line, which features Erik Haula between Neal and Alex Tuch . Defensively, the Winnipeg Jets are allowing 2.6 goals per game and are killing 81.8 percent of their opponents power plays.
    'We got Bama!': Crimson Tide rolls into Austin in 2022

    'We got Bama!': Crimson Tide rolls into Austin in 2022

    His work has been featured on Sports Illustrated, ESPN.com, FOXSports.com, CBSSports.com and many others. The Longhorns will now host the Buckeyes on August 30, 2025, and travel to Columbus on September 5, 2026.
    ND Senate discuss net neutrality, plan moving forward

    ND Senate discuss net neutrality, plan moving forward

    Net neutrality, under which the internet has operated since its inception, ensures that there is no favoritism in internet access. Once there, the caucus would need a simple majority to adopt the resolution - and with Collins, it has 50 votes.


Most liked

French Oil Firm May Leave Iran
In a deal first signed in late 2016, Total agreed to operate the South Pars project with a stake of 50.1%. The European Union, also a signatory to the atomic deal, has pledged to take steps to salvage the accord.

Facebook rolls out Stories archive and voice posts, starting in India
Finally, Facebook will let you archive your stories like it does on Instagram so you can save the stories you like the most. These memories can be seen right when you log into your Facebook account and help you save the storage on your smartphone.

Supreme Court to examine Centre's Cauvery management scheme today
The Supreme Court on Wednesday had directed Centre to make a few modifications to the draft it had submitted on May 14. Karnataka and Tamil Nadu have fought over the river for more than a century now.

Discovery of distant galaxy opens door to 'uncharted period of cosmic history'
If astronomers discovered oxygen in MACS1149-JD1, it meant that inside the galaxy, stars have formed even earlier and died in the galaxy.

Atletico bid to erase pain of finals past in Marseille showdown
Since then it is Barcelona who have emerged as the leading contender to sign the former Real Sociedad man and have been tipped to meet his €100million buy out.

SC collegium defers reiteration of Justice Joseph's elevation to top court
The collegium intends to send Justice Joseph's name along with other names being considered for Supreme Court judgeships. Justice Jhala's name has been approved after taking into consideration the material on record .

Seven Teams Earn NCAA Public Recognition Awards
Five Canisius programs recognized were men's cross country , golf , men's swimming and diving, men's track and field and rowing . The aggregate 2016-17 Academic Progress Rate data for all NCAA Division I institutions will be announced later this month.

Pope 'very worried' by Gaza violence
Eight children under the age of 16, including an eight-month-old baby, were among Monday's dead. Calling for "dialogue, justice and peace", said violence "has never led to peace".

US, Gulf Arab states place sanctions on Hezbollah leadership
Specifically, OFAC, together with Gulf partners, designated Hasan Nasrallah, the Secretary General of Hezbollah. The sanctions target Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah, his deputy Naim Qassem and other figures and entities.

Kane on 'amazing' Salah: 'I haven't seen Mo to talk with him'
With 44 goals and 14 assists in 52 games for club and country, Salah has placed himself among the world's elite forwards. Klopp's players reassemble in Marbella on Wednesday after a couple of days off for a short training camp.

Increasing concern as Ebola outbreak spreads to city in DR Congo
It can spread rapidly through contact with small amounts of bodily fluid and its early flu-like symptoms are not always obvious. It involves vaccinating voluntary contacts, contacts of those contacts and health care and other front-line workers.

Disgraced Parkland officer will get pension
Fathers of two of the victims of the Parkland shooting expressed their disgust over Peterson's generous pension on Twitter . Peterson rushed to the building, but stayed outside for about four minutes during the shooting and never went inside.

YouTube just added songwriter, label and publisher credits to millions of songs
Now, these credits will natively appear on both music videos and user-uploaded content that features recorded songs. That being the case, the implementation of " Music in this Video " is still a net positive for all those concerned.

Caged tiger at Florida high school prom causes uproar
Some parents in Florida are very upset after learning there was a caged tiger at their kids' high school prom over the weekend. It isn't hard to imagine a teen sticking their hand in the cage or getting close enough to be mauled by the anxious big cat.

JR Smith Won't be Disciplined for Flagrant Foul
The relentless pressure and intensity of the Celtics continued to wear on the Cavs, as Boston were just kicking into gear. LeBron James responded to his weak game one performance with one of the best playoff quarters of his career.