Scottish parliament refuses consent for Britain's European Union withdrawal bill

Scottish independence is never off the table Sturgeon says

In the case of the EU Withdrawal Bill the UK Government has been clear it will not remove clause 11 from the legislation, despite protestations from Scottish ministers that measures in this will constrain Holyrood's powers for up to seven years.

The Westminster government has offered concessions to devolved administrations and May's Conservative party points out that these have been enough for the Welsh government to drop their reservations about the bill.

Scottish ministers contend that the devolved parliaments should have to give express consent for changes to these frameworks, while the United Kingdom side argues that this would effectively give MSPs the power of veto over frameworks extending right across the country.

Scotland's parliament doesn't have the authority to block the legislation, but an attempt to push it through without Scottish consent could prompt a constitutional crisis.

The British government will press ahead with the EU Withdrawal Bill despite the Scottish parliament's decision to withhold its consent for the legislation.

Bruce Crawford, the head of the Parliament's Finance and Constitution Committee, said the vote was a "historic and significant" moment for Scotland and that he hoped the government in London would "respect the views" of the assembly.

With the European Union withdrawal bill due for its final vote in the Commons within weeks, May is running out of time to reach a deal before it becomes law.


"If they now move to force on this parliament an arrangement for restricting devolution that does not have parliament's consent they will do so in the full knowledge that they are breaking the twenty year old devolution settlement and operating out with the agreed constitution".

The problem is that clause 15 of that bill automatically transfers those new powers to Whitehall.

Scotland voted on independence in 2014, before Brexit.

The SNP said it would be "outrageous" for the British government to impose the bill on Scotland.

SNP, Labour, Green and Liberal Democrat MSPs voted against the EU Withdrawal bill, while Scottish Conservatives argued the Bill protects Scotland's devolved powers.

Scottish Labour leader Richard Leonard, who has been calling for cross party talks to resolve the dispute, said: 'This means that the vote on consent for the Withdrawal Bill at Holyrood today need not be the final word on this matter. It's not in Scotland's interests that the SNP prefers picking fights to making a deal'.

Related News:

  • Advocates Question Facebook's Latest Effort To Protect Data

    Advocates Question Facebook's Latest Effort To Protect Data

    It soaked up data of some 87 million Facebook users because it was able to gain access to friends of people who used it. With that password, virtually anyone could have access to a trove of information on around 3 million Facebook users.
    Seven Governors Sign Letter Supporting Trump For Nobel Peace Prize

    Seven Governors Sign Letter Supporting Trump For Nobel Peace Prize

    Paul LePage has signed a letter with 6 fellow governors backing President Trump's nomination for the Nobel Peace Prize . The letter is also signed by the governors of Alabama, Guam, Kansas, Mississippi, Maine and West Virginia.
    Airbus co-pilot is sucked halfway out of cockpit window

    Airbus co-pilot is sucked halfway out of cockpit window

    Even with all of that going on, the plane was able to land safely in another part of China after the break. 'I'm still nervous . A flight out of China made an emergency landing after a copilot was sucked halfway out of the aircraft's cockpit .
  • Wife attacked former US Open champ over bad round

    Wife attacked former US Open champ over bad round

    Following the tournament's third round, Krista Glover was arrested and charged with domestic battery and resisting arrest. Glover and his mother were both found with lacerations on their arms, while his mother also had blood on her clothes.
    AU condemns Israel's

    AU condemns Israel's "disproportionate" use of force against Palestinians

    Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu said his forces were acting in self-defence against Gaza's Islamist rulers, Hamas. Earlier Monday, the Palestinian UN envoy urged the United Nations' most powerful body to condemn the killings.
    Rihanna's Alleged Stalker Waited In Her Home for 12 Hours

    Rihanna's Alleged Stalker Waited In Her Home for 12 Hours

    He is scheduled to be arraigned on Monday in the Foltz Criminal Justice Centre in Los Angeles , officials said. In 2016 a man was investigated after sending a death threat to Rihanna and taking a selfie outside her home.
  • Malaysian former deputy PM Anwar to be released on Wednesday

    Malaysian former deputy PM Anwar to be released on Wednesday

    A royal pardon would reverse Mr Anwar's conviction and make him eligible to actively participate in politics. Mr Mahathir has promised to step aside for Mr Anwar to become prime minister within two years.
    Cam Smith calls time on rep career

    Cam Smith calls time on rep career

    Regardless, Smith will depart the representative arena as one of the most prolific players at the game's highest level. "I probably started having thoughts about finishing up my representative career a year ago ".
    Died the founder of

    Died the founder of "new journalism" of Tom Wolfe

    Wolfe is survived by Sheila Wolfe, his wife of almost 40 years; a son, Tommy Wolfe, and a daughter, Alexandra Wolfe. The film version of "The Right Stuff ", about the Mercury Seven astronauts, was directed by Philip Kaufman in 1983.
  • Europe, Iran seek to save nuclear deal after United States  withdraws

    Europe, Iran seek to save nuclear deal after United States withdraws

    The deal focused on limiting and monitoring Iran's production of nuclear fuel, a key ingredient for producing such weapons. Russian Federation and Iran once had hard relations, but have seen ties improve since the end of the Cold War.
    Keyless-ignition cars are killing people

    Keyless-ignition cars are killing people

    According to the Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE), they had published safety recommendations for keyless cars back in 2011. While convenient, keyless cars can sometimes have a deadly effect, according to a report from the New York Times .
    World Health Organization  leads push to universally ban trans fats

    World Health Organization leads push to universally ban trans fats

    They became popular in the 1950s through 1970s with the discovery of the negative health impacts of saturated fatty acids. In the USA , the first trans fatty food to hit the market was Crisco shortening, which went on sale in 1911.


Most liked

23 missing after boat carrying 40 capsizes in Andhra Pradesh's Godavari river
Fishermen raced to the scene to help, and officials deployed police and a team from the National Disasters Relief Force. The boat, which sailed from Kondamodalu , was on its way Rajamahendravaram.

Ronaldo, Carvajal back in full Real Madrid training
Marcelo told reporters : "The best come to Madrid and I would love to play with Neymar. The fact that these things are spoken of about me, well, that's that.

Alan Shearer doesn't buy Mike Ashley's very defensive end of season statement
In Spain and in Italy there are many things: when I arrived in England at Liverpool, they gave me three years to win something. You will need some money, and you will need a way to spend that money.

North Dakota Joins Lawsuit Against Drug Maker Purdue Pharma
The Attorney General says filing a lawsuit is an important step in fighting addiction by going after the root of the problem. Nationwide, there were 42,249 opioid overdoses in 2016, including 1,375 opioid-related deaths in Texas.

European Union still providing illegal subsidies to Airbus
We likewise expect Boeing to take note when it comes to its compliance obligations. USA top aircraft manufacturer Boeing Co .

Facebook and Twitter cleaning up fake accounts
In a blog post, the company claimed that the most of the accounts "were disabled within minutes of registration". Luckily for Facebook, almost all of that content was scrubbed from the social network by its technology.

Champions Parade: Manchester is Blue!
Third-placed Tottenham Hotspur made a thrilling 5-4 win over Leicester City , who finished ninth. Teams playing in the league continued to battle hard even on the very last day of the season.

NASS inflates 2018 budget from 8.6trn to N9.120trn
The report of the Committee on Appropriations of the Senate was laid by the Chairman, Senator Danjuma Goje , APC, Gombe Central. The delay had prompted President Muhammadu Buhari to issue a deadline to heads of all MDAs to defend their budgets unfailingly.

American's New Support Animal Policy to Take Effect July 1
Passengers with a support animal have always had to provide a letter from their mental health professional. American Airlines reported an increase of more than 40% between 2016 and 2017.

Robinson Cano To Be Suspended 80 Games ... for Steroids
Heyman adds that the Cano suspension is for a diuretic (furosemide), which is seen as a masking agent . I apologize to my family, friends, fans, team-mates and the Mariners organization.

Should Wolves look at Joe Hart with World Cup snub looming?
There is some debate about the midfielders that Gareth Southgate should take with him to Russian Federation . The 28-year-old has been more naturally a central midfielder and brings versatility to Southgate's squad.

Dutch researchers read two covered pages of Anne Frank diary
The Anne Frank House, a museum located in Frank's former hiding place, did not quote directly from the text it had recovered. Frank's candid words on sex didn't make it into the first published diary, which appeared in English in 1952.

This graduating class pulled off an awesome senior prank
Senior class prank season tests the patience of the adults in the room and the adults of Cumberland, Wis ., have passed the test. When the local police congratulate the entire class on their senior prank, you know they pulled off something great.

What do you hear? 'Yanny' vs 'Laurel' dividing the internet
Some Twitter uses suggested a change of frequency, possibly through a change of speakers , could determine what you hear. The word being spoken isn't quite yanny or laurel , says Brown University phonetician Chelsea Sanker.

Villa hold off Boro to reach Championship playoff final
With respect to Fulham (and Birmingham) fans, it's easy to make Villa the emotional favorite of the playoff final. Villa were relegated from the Premier League at the end of the 2015-16 season.