U.S. transport safety board finds Uber software at fault for fatal collision

U.S. transport safety board finds Uber software at fault for fatal collision

The initial report by the National Transportation Safety Board on the fatal self-driving Uber crash in March confirms that the auto detected the pedestrian as early as 6 seconds before the crash, but did not slow or stop because its emergency braking systems were deliberately disabled. The organization is clear that the document "does not contain probably cause" but does give much more detail about the crash than has previously been released. "Everyone on our roads shares the responsibility for safety, and Uber blatantly neglected to do its part". The report claimed the sensors on Uber's self-driving Volvo detected the woman crossing the street with a bicycle outside of a crosswalk but decided not to immediately act. It paints a damning picture of Uber's self-driving technology.

The SUV also lacked a way to alert the human driver behind the wheel to manually brake. "Many of the issues raised in the report lead right back to Uber and Uber's testing program as a legitimate target of criticism". As part of that process, Uber hired Christopher Hart, a former chairman of the National Transportation Safety Board, to review its self-driving auto program.

Data from the auto shows the autonomous system first registered LIDAR and radar observations of the pedestrian around 6 seconds prior to impact.

Uber's computer-vision software initially classified her as an unknown object, then as another vehicle, before deciding she was actually a bicycle and couldn't predict the direction she was going to go.

One of Uber's self-driving cars killed a pedestrian crossing the road at night because its emergency braking systems were turned off, according to an investigation by the USA government's National Transport Safety Board. Human chaperones are supposed to take control when the cars' sensors and algorithms fall short or other circumstances demand it. It didn't have a specific comment on the NTSB report.

The system relied on the human backup driver to intervene but is not now able to alert the driver of any unsafe situations.


The report goes on to say that the self-driving system actually saw Herzberg six seconds before the impact occurred.

According to the investigators, the unmanned vehicle spotted the danger and determined the need to stop 1.3 seconds before the fatal crash. That's described as a decision made "to reduce the potential for erratic vehicle behavior". The safety-first approach that AV developers should rightly be adopting when dealing with hazards will naturally turn up a lot of false positives.

This image from the NTSB report shows that the auto identified the object as a bicycle at least 1.3 seconds before impact.

Volvo Cars equipped the vehicle with several advanced driver-assistance systems, including a collision-avoidance function with automatic emergency braking as well as functions for detecting driver alertness and road-sign information. "We're easily distracted, and we have slower reaction times", Samaras added.

In fact, the Uber spokesperson, who asked not to be named for this article, said that backup drivers "are not required to do anything with the diagnostics". The National Transportation Safety Board released a preliminary report Thursday on the collision.

Vasquez didn't seem impaired to Tempe police, and she wasn't tested for alcohol or drugs, the report says.

Related News:

  • Paul receiving regular treatment to return for Rockets

    They lost to the Cavs in the NBA Finals, but that series win set things up for Kevin Durant to eventually join the team . But it's important to remember that the Warriors never needed Durant; he was the cherry on top of a formidable roster.
    Two injured in  IN school shooting, suspect arrested

    Two injured in IN school shooting, suspect arrested

    The suspect had excused himself from class at Noblesville West Middle School and came back armed with the pistols and opened fire. Sandy McWilliams, a member of a landscaping crew, said six officers with assault rifles entered a home.
    Unusual  wolf-like animal killed in Montana puzzles wildlife officials

    Unusual wolf-like animal killed in Montana puzzles wildlife officials

    But others think it is a coywolf (a coyote wolf hybrid), or perhaps a wolfdog bred in captivity and later released into the wild. They are now relying on DNA tests to determine exactly what the species is.
  • Trump seethes over Russian Federation  probe, calls for end to 'SPYGATE'

    Trump seethes over Russian Federation probe, calls for end to 'SPYGATE'

    A CBS News poll in early May, for example, showed how widely his talking points are being embraced. It is refreshing to hear that now, finally, he's interested in actual evidence.
    Trump not backing down on 'spy' allegations

    Trump not backing down on 'spy' allegations

    Adam Schiff (D-Calif.), the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, criticized as "completely inappropriate". That explanation has not satisfied many Democrats. "If the facts are against you, argue the law", the saying goes.
    Nipah scare: Patient who visited Kerala is on ventilator support

    Nipah scare: Patient who visited Kerala is on ventilator support

    There is no real treatment but supportive care is given to the affected patients, which means treating the symptoms differently. After the recent Nipah virus outbreak, social media users have gone overboard spreading panic among citizens, said Dr N.
  • Seoul: North Korea committed to US summit, denuclearization

    Seoul: North Korea committed to US summit, denuclearization

    Mr Trump welcomed the North's conciliatory response to his Thursday letter withdrawing from the Singapore summit with Kim Jong-un. The tweet comes after the historic summit was called into question when Mr Trump pulled out on Thursday after talks deteriorated.
    US Mississippi, Florida Declare Emergency Over Subtropical Storm Alberto

    US Mississippi, Florida Declare Emergency Over Subtropical Storm Alberto

    Monday looks like the rainiest, windiest day with an increasing threat of some tornadoes east of wherever the center ends up. The last time a tropical cyclone was named Alberto was in 2012; it also formed before the season began, on May 19.

    Nvidia Shield updates to Android TV Oreo 8.0 with custom menus

    As we reported earlier today, Honor has started pushing the Android 8.0 Oreo update for the budget Honor 7X in India. The "Play Next" option lets you add content so you can restart watching if you don't finish a show, movie, or game.
  • Emmanuel Macron and Vladimir Putin: 'Frenemies' reunited

    Emmanuel Macron and Vladimir Putin: 'Frenemies' reunited

    While criticizing the USA policy on Iran, Putin had some warm words for Trump and held out hope for holding a summit with him. The two leaders have now met 21 times, including at a hot springs resort in Abe's hometown of Nagato in 2016.
    Ireland Votes To Overturn Abortion Ban by a Landslide - Lauretta Brown

    Ireland Votes To Overturn Abortion Ban by a Landslide - Lauretta Brown

    The "Yes" campaign was backed by Ireland's Indian origin Prime Minister Leo Varadkar . Varadkar told RTE, Ireland's public broadcaster.
    Lewis Hamilton and Sebastian Vettel open to future partnership

    Lewis Hamilton and Sebastian Vettel open to future partnership

    French driver Romain Grosjean, who has failed to finish three of five races so far, twice clipped the barriers in P1. He is the only driver yet to score a point along with Russian driver Sergey Sirotkin from the Williams team.


Most liked

Dirty Sergio Ramos Challenge Ends Mo Salah’s Champions League Final
Lallana also lauded Firmino's two partners in crime, Salah and Mane, adding: "Sadio is a match victor ". As for veteran footballer Ronaldo, this will be his 17th major club cup final and 18 cup final in total.

Rashid Khan is a keen follower of Mahesh Babu’s films
Sunrisers are one from one in finals, having beaten RCB by eight runs in a run-fest in 2016 under the stewardship of David Warner. Kane Williamson and MS Dhoni take on each other as not only captains leading from the front, but also as middle order mainstays.

Klopp calls for 'big balls' from Liverpool
Carvajal missed most of the semi-final through injury but is back in the side and will be in for a tough time up against Salah. Fox is included in the package so you'll be able to quickly join in time to watch the entire Liverpool vs Real Madrid game .

Cairney the hero as Fulham strike it rich with Premier League promotion
Between them, they gladly hoovered up danger and it was only Grealish, the dancing Villa playmaker who Fulham failed to mute. Aston Villa , meanwhile, is looking to return to the top flight after two seasons in the Championship .

Moonwalking astronaut-artist Alan Bean dies at 86
Alan Bean the fourth astronaut to walk on the moon before becoming a painter died Saturday at the age of 86 in Texas . We invite you to share condolences for Alan Bean in our Guest Book .

Rockets battle Warriors in Game 6 of Western Conference finals
We want to see your fan photos and videos! Paul did not even address the media post game because he was busy receiving treatment. The Warriors are hoping for the return of Andre Iguodala , who's missed the last two games, both losses, with a knee injury.

Trump says Korea talks 'going along very well'
In response, the North said Friday that it stays open to talks with the USA anytime and in any format. Moon says his meeting with Kim was arranged at Kim's request.

Meghan Markle’s Royal Coat of Arms Pays Homage to California
The Coats of Arms of members of the Royal Family are broadly similar to The Queen's with small differences to differentiate them. Kensington Palace released the coat of arms, incorporates strong symbolism drawing on Markle's life, Friday.

Dark Souls Remastered Steam Release Comes a Day Early
For the Dark Souls fan that wants everything there's now a 100% pure bronze grail you can buy, and you won't believe the price... The game's opening Asylum area as well as the Undead Cathedral among others were equally smooth on both consoles.

Russia Downplays Dutch-Led Investigation Into the Downing of MH17
Russian Federation has always denied involvement in the downing of the aircraft and blamed Ukraine for the incident. All 298 passengers and crew, majority Dutch, were killed in the disaster.

LeBron Scores 46, Cavaliers Beat Celtics 109-99 To Force Game 7
That season, Boston knocked out James and the Cavs in six games in the second round, and James left the Cavs for the Miami Heat. George Hill added 20 points, while Jeff Green and Larry Nance came off the bench to deliver 14 and 10, respectively.

Sesame Street sues 'explicit and profane' puppet movie The Happytime Murders
Sesame Workshop seeks a permanent injunction on the use of its marks in connection with the marketing of The Happytime Murders . The Muppets have been a key part of " Sesame Street " since 1969.

Iran presses European Union on measures to salvage nuclear deal
Plan B has just started to be figured out". "European banks should safeguard trade with the Islamic Republic", Khamenei said. They have said that as long as Tehran meets its commitments, they will stick to the deal.

Washington Capitals heading to Stanley Cup final after beating Lightning 4-0
The team now plays the Golden Knights in the Stanley Cup final, which begins on Monday. "We're not going to be suck this year", he said.

Liverpool v Real Madrid: James Milner stuns teammates with wondergoal in training
That would equal the individual record, and leave him in sight of yet another Ballon d'Or. In terms of history alone, this is a dream final.