EU Rubbishes Labour's Brexit Vision, Calling it "Cakeism"

Anti-Brexit demonstrators gather outside the Houses of Parliament in London England. Chris J Ratcliffe Getty Images

Britain's Brexit minister told parliament on Tuesday to back down in a showdown over Prime Minister Theresa May's plans for leaving the European Union, warning lawmakers they could undermine negotiations with Brussels.

Following its defeat, the government's own amendment on the so-called meaningful vote will go forward to the House of Lords for debate next week - but with some changes.

There was little doubt the government would win on the customs union and single market, which some pro-EU lawmakers say is the only way for Britain to retain economically advantageous close ties with the bloc, with the opposition Labour Party also divided over future relations.

Brexit backers see this clause as weakening the government's negotiating position, as they want May to be able to threaten to walk away.

That said, while the government may have won the battle on customs, the war is still to come.

If the government avoids defeat, is Brexit a done deal?

In a day of drama, May's position seemed suddenly weaker when junior justice minister Phillip Lee, who has always been critical of Brexit strategy, resigned and said he would vote against the government. But she faces a gruelling bout of "parliamentary ping-pong" with the Lords, as the Bill bounces back and forth between the two Houses over the coming weeks.

"What would be the result to our government if we lost this vote today?" asked Conservative lawmaker Edward Leigh.


So it's worth remembering that while the government didn't lose any votes yesterday, Mrs May was forced into some embarrassing climb-downs that could come back to haunt her.

Conservative lawmakers Anna Soubry, Ken Clarke and Dominic Grieve had expressed their support for a greater parliamentary role in scrutinising the government's Brexit bill during debates on Tuesday. By 2pm the only speeches had been from the two main frontbench spokesmen (Brexit minister, David Davis, and Labour's Matthew Pennycook).

In a concession, the government promised that lawmakers would have a say on what to do next if there is no agreement with the European Union, or if Parliament rejects the deal offered. MPs will vote on this particular amendment this afternoon. And overnight the former Cabinet minister has tabled a late, late amendment that gives the PM a little more wriggle room until 15 February, while insisting Parliament should get a binding vote if it doesn't like the outcome.

The amendment, in similar terms, calls for the government to join the European Free Trade Association - along with Norway - and maintain its membership of the European Economic Area.

British lawmakers voted down an amendment that would give Members of Parliament the power to veto the government's Brexit deal with Brussels.

May objected to the amendment - inserted by the House of Lords - because she said it would tie her hands in the negotiation. He added: "I understand the difficulties MPs representing constituencies which voted strongly for Leave or Remain have on the EEA amendment". After a bumpy week of Brexit spats within her administration and with the EU, May wants to fend off another setback in a long-awaited showdown with restive lawmakers.

May said the government would amend the bill to address legislators' concerns, but warned that "I can not countenance Parliament being able to overturn the will of the British people".

Related News:

  • Jada Pinkett-Smith Says Her Grandmother Taught Her About Masturbation At 9

    Jada Pinkett-Smith Says Her Grandmother Taught Her About Masturbation At 9

    Jada asked what her daughter's feelings were about that incident and Willow said she had simply "overstepped a boundary". Anne-Marie Tomchak talks artificial intelligence and the robot take-over on #GirlsWithGoals.is your job truly safe? .
    United's new midfielder injured in Brazil training

    United's new midfielder injured in Brazil training

    Fred has made eight appearances for Brazil and made head coach Tite's final 23-man squad for the World Cup in Russian Federation . Lasmar said Augusto could play on Sunday depending on how his recovery continues this week.
    Particles from early solar system found in comet dust

    Particles from early solar system found in comet dust

    The nanoscale GEMS subgrains are bound together by dense organic carbon in clusters comprising the GEMS grains. The team's insights will be significant in the deeper understanding of how the universe was formed.
  • US, Mexico and Canada to host 2026 World Cup

    US, Mexico and Canada to host 2026 World Cup

    The bid group has been working under the premise of three cities in each of Canada and Mexico and 10 in the United States. Despite this, Solkowski is hearing there's still a slight chance Vancouver could get back in the game, so to speak.
    La Barbie sentenced to 49 years in prison

    La Barbie sentenced to 49 years in prison

    At the time, then-Mexican President Felipe Calderon called Villarreal 'one of the most-wanted criminals in Mexico and overseas '. Duffey wasn't swayed, telling Valdez that his actions were despicable and amounted to a betrayal of his family and his country.
    N Korea media highlights Trump concessions on war games

    N Korea media highlights Trump concessions on war games

    North Korea has been an isolated nation since it first divided from South Korea after the end of World War II in 1945. Trump and Kim were returning to their respective strongholds following the talks - but to far different receptions.
  • Martian rover threatened by massive dust storm

    Martian rover threatened by massive dust storm

    That means Opportunity's solar panels aren't getting enough sunlight to phone home from its Perseverance Valley location on Mars. Opportunity was in remarkably good health going into the storm, Callas said, with only an arthritic joint in its robotic arm.
    FG declares Friday, Monday, public holidays for Eid -El Fitr

    FG declares Friday, Monday, public holidays for Eid -El Fitr

    The Central Ruet-e-Hilal Committee will meet on Thursday evening in Karachi for Shawal moon sighting. These institutions will resume normal operations on Wednesday, June 20, sources said.
    Angelina Jolie Could Lose Physical Custody of Kids to Brad Pitt

    Angelina Jolie Could Lose Physical Custody of Kids to Brad Pitt

    Pitt gets custody from June 8 to June 17 for four hours per day while he stays in London, where Jolie now rents a house. Angelina Jolie has allegedly been ordered to allow estranged husband Brad Pitt to spend more time with their children.
  • Garmin Vivoactive 3 Music First Look

    Garmin Vivoactive 3 Music First Look

    Deezer is given as an example of one such service, but apparently support for this is coming soon rather than being available now. Still, if you're into athletic activities, it's hard to compete against this bad boy at $300.
    North Korea Summit: Best Donald Trump & Kim Jong-un Memes

    North Korea Summit: Best Donald Trump & Kim Jong-un Memes

    However, there was no mention of the previous USA aim of "complete, verifiable and irreversible denuclearization" from Pyongyang. On Wednesday morning, he took to Twitter to claim there was "no longer" a nuclear threat posed by the North Korean regime.
    First official screenshots for Cyberpunk 2077 released

    First official screenshots for Cyberpunk 2077 released

    As you explore the Net, you'll discover layers of hidden systems, firewalls and security programs deployed to fry your brain. This is a dark game intended for a mature audience and as it turns out, Night City is a pretty grim place to live.


Most liked

Fed lifts rates amid stronger inflation, drops crisis-era guidance
After years in which the economy expanded at roughly a tepid 2 percent annually, growth could top 3 percent this year. All those countries have vowed to retaliate against any US tariffs with their own penalties against USA goods.

Judge approves $85 billion AT&T-Time Warner deal
And the company said it plans to close the merger, which was announced a year and a half ago, on or before June 20. The decision comes despite criticism from Trump, a frequent detractor of Time Warner's CNN and its coverage.

Couple taking selfie on cliff plunge to their deaths
The captain of the port of Cascais, 30 kilometres west of Lisbon, said he believed the couple fell while trying to take a selfie. The couple's bodies were taken to a medical centre while authorities contacted the Australian and British embassies in Lisbon.

Shami fails fitness test, Saini called in as replacement for Afghanistan Test
The key for me is fitness and over the last few months, I have brought a lot of changes into my fitness regimen. Despite all the odds, the Afghans will look to put up a spirited performance against the top-ranked Test team.

Prince Harry and Meghan's first major royal tour confirmed
The work is a fee for the right of man to dwell on the earth. "There are no special classes, there are no special manuals". As a newly-appointed royal with the world watching her every move, you certainly can't blame Meghan for feeling nervous.

German prosecutor hits Volkswagen with €1B Dieselgate fine
VW said it held a board meeting to discuss the crisis, with members of the supervisory board also being informed. VW said that it accepted the fine, and would not appeal.

Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu And Eevee Require A Subscription To Play Online
The game can also be integrated with PPokemon Go app and transfer their Pokemon from the app to the Switch game. Will there be motion controls in Pokemon Let's Go Pikachu if I'm playing in handheld mode?

Urges all parties in Yemen to work with United Nations as fighting flares
He estimates that over a million people live in the greater Hodeidah area which is expected to be targeted in the offensive. The officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to brief the media.

Trump vents anger on North Atlantic Treaty Organisation allies, European Union and Canada's Trudeau
European officials said Trump had tried to water down the language in the draft communique on the WTO and rules-based trade. USA allies will "be looking forward to the day when there's a different government in the United States", he said.

Ubisoft Releases New Transference Trailer at E3 2018
The live-action storyline will shift between three different perspectivesm as you unravel the mystery at the heart of the family. Transference is now slated for Fall of this year, though we assume as it gets closer, a more precise date will be offered.

Paul raccoon safely trapped on tower roof
By Wednesday morning it had made it to the roof of the building, easing fears that it would plummet to its death. A raccoon scrambles along a ledge on the side of the Town Square building in downtown St.

Macedonia to be called 'Republic of Northern Macedonia'
That challenge will still be a mountain to climb, as Greek Prime Minister Tsipras has not yet secured any support in parliament. Zaev said resolving the longstanding issue would open Macedonia's access to North Atlantic Treaty Organisation and the EU.

Nintendo announces Daemon X Machina at its E3 presentation
It is coming out for the Switch in 2019 from Marvelous, a publisher in Japan. Daemon X Machina will come to the Nintendo Switch in 2019.

E3 2018: Bethesda's Starfield May Not Release On Current-Gen Consoles
The big picture: Even though Bethesda announced that Elder Scrolls VI is in the works does not mean that we will see it soon. Elder Scrolls 5: Skyrim was released back in 2011 and is now playable on every device known to man, including smart fridges.

'Luke Cage' Season 2 Trailer Features Mariah Dillard, Bushmaster
After all, he's Harlem's hero, and Harlem's hero works against criminals, not with them. He is forced to confront the fine line that separates a hero from a villain.