Section 377: Government leaves decision to the wisdom of the Supreme Court

KK Venugopal

"We are (debating) on whether the relationship between two adults is itself a manifestation of Article 21 of the Constitution", he said.

"Unnatural offences. -Whoever voluntarily has carnal intercourse against the order of nature with any man, woman or animal, shall be punished with 1 [imprisonment for life], or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine". The determination of order of nature is not a constant phenomenon. He said "pre-constitutional law like section 377" will have to go as it does not conform to the Constitution.

In 2009 the Delhi High Court effectively decriminalised gay sex, saying a ban violated fundamental rights, but the Supreme Court reinstated it in 2013 after religious groups successfully appealed. According to BuzzFeed News, the Supreme Court argued in that ruling that India's LGBTQ community was small relative to the country's population and that few people had ever been prosecuted under Section 377.

The hearing comes nearly a year after the Supreme Court ruled that individual privacy is a fundamental right, a verdict constitutional experts say has a bearing on the homosexuality ban.

Subsequently in December 2013, an Apex Court bench in the Kaushal case, reversed the High Court verdict and upheld the constitutional validity of Section 377.

Others who have filed petitions against section 377 are journalist Sunil Mehra, chef Ritu Dalmia, hotelier Aman Nath and business executive Ayesha Kapur. They also contended that a larger constitution bench be formed to hear all petitions on the issue. "Those are individual issues we can not pre-judge now", Chief Justice of India (CJI) Dipak Misra said.


The court will begin hearing numerous petitions arguing that gay sex between consenting adults must be made legal.

The assurance to the Centre came after additional solicitor-general Tushar Mehta objected to a suggestion from Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, another judge on the bench headed by the CJI. The top court on Monday refused to adjourn the hearing despite the Centre's plea for more time to file its response on the issue.

ASG Mehta said that if the right to chose sexual partner is declared a fundamental right, then somebody may come up and say that he or she wanted to marry a sibling, which would be contrary to the laws governing to marriages. Counsel for the petitioners will continue with their submissions today.

In a short affidavit, the government told the court that it should decide only whether Section IPC 377 needed to be criminalised and no other issue. 20 of them had written their personal encounters, the key highlights of which pointed to one factor- discrimination based on their sexual orientation.

"The Petitioners can not overcome a lurking fear that their consensual relationships, even within the privacy of their homes, may invite coercive state action at the hands of a busybody, rival, political party, or any other 3rd party who has no bona fide interest with the private lives of the Petitioners, and is motivated only by malice/prejudice", stated the petition.

Related News:

  • Kim sets 54-hole record, Talley 3rd at LPGA Classic

    Kim sets 54-hole record, Talley 3rd at LPGA Classic

    Kim began the final round with an 8 shot lead and wound up winning by nine in collecting the unique Sky Woman trophy. During her first season on the LPGA Tour , Kim won three tournaments to earn the Tour's Rookie of the Year award.
    Pakistan win T20 tri-series final against Australia

    Pakistan win T20 tri-series final against Australia

    He dipped from there, but 6 and 19 in the next two games ensured he was up nine spots since the last update at 812 points. Finch, Zaman, and KL Rahul replaced an injured Babar Azam , Colin Munro and Glenn Maxwell in the top three spots.
    Mission Continues in Rescue of Thai Soccer Team

    Mission Continues in Rescue of Thai Soccer Team

    A family member told CNN Monday that they hadn't been told which boys had been pulled out, and who is still trapped in the cave. Their escape led to an explosion of jubilation on social media in Thailand as the rescued boys were rushed to hospital.
  • Belgium’s Courtois blasts France victory as ‘shame for football’

    Belgium’s Courtois blasts France victory as ‘shame for football’

    Martinez is not a man known for his defensive organisation but France will make him think twice and maybe thrice. France controlled the early tempo of the game but Belgium had more possession in the earlier stages.
    ANP leader Haroon Bilour among 20 martyred in Peshawar blast

    ANP leader Haroon Bilour among 20 martyred in Peshawar blast

    Presently, 62 people injured in suicide attack are seeking treatment at Lady Reading Hospital, authorities confirmed. This is the second terrorist attack on an election rally in Pakistan ahead of the July 25 general election.
    Turkey sacks 18,500 staff before expected end of coup emergency

    Turkey sacks 18,500 staff before expected end of coup emergency

    Mr Erdogan will be sworn in on Monday under a new executive presidency after his outright victory in the June 24 elections. In addition, the decree states that 148 people, fired by previous decrees, are reinstated in the public administration.
  • Serena sets sights on eighth Wimbledon title

    Serena sets sights on eighth Wimbledon title

    Even when Serena was on the brink of losing the set, she managed to hit a 122 miles per hour serve, her fastest of the tournament. But as she has done at each stage here, in just her fourth tournament back since maternity leave, Williams elevated her play.
    Insurers warn of rising premiums after Trump axes Obamacare payments again

    Insurers warn of rising premiums after Trump axes Obamacare payments again

    But CareFirst and Kaiser could ask to adjust their rates higher given the Trump administration's decision. The payments insurers expected this fall, based on their 2017 business, amounted to $10.4 billion.
    Jaded Croatia look to master Modric to carry them through against England

    Jaded Croatia look to master Modric to carry them through against England

    Belgium finally showed on the pitch why so many rate them so highly and have tipped them to do well in this tournament. Like England , France have won one World Cup , and also like England it took place on home soil.
  • Chelsea's Thibaut Courtois: Madrid-based children key to decision on future

    Chelsea's Thibaut Courtois: Madrid-based children key to decision on future

    Courtois has his ex wife and two children win Madrid to fuel speculation that the Belgium global could return to the Spanish capital.

    Video shows George Clooney hurt in Italian scooter crash

    George Clooney is on the mend after a scary scooter accident in Italy . 'George was treated and released from an Olbia hospital. Clooney was driving a motor scooter to work on Tuesday morning when he collided with a Mercedes making a sudden left turn.
    Thai cave rescue: All 12 boys and soccer coach freed

    Thai cave rescue: All 12 boys and soccer coach freed

    When asked about his first reaction as he saw the first set of boys who were rescued he admitted that he was "very scared. Four boys were rescued from the underground caves on Sunday, bringing the total number of recovered children to eight.


Most liked

Meghan Markle STUNS in dress as Prince Harry says ‘IT’S COMING HOME’
Prince Harry and Meghan Markle will travel to Ireland on their first official overseas visit as a married couple . The couple attended a garden party at the British Ambassador's residence at Glencairn.

Sterling at heart of Englands bid despite goal drought
Dier, while speaking at a press conference ahead of England versus Croatia match on Wednesday, said Sterling has been "incredible" before and now.

Germany ‘totally controlled by Russia,’ Trump tells North Atlantic Treaty Organisation chief
Trump was referring to a 2015 agreement between Russian gas giant Gazprom and Germany to build a pipeline under the Baltic Sea. And maybe we'll speak to him when I get over there. "On that point the American friends have a point", von der Leyen said .

A look back at Trump's strained Twitter relationship with the UK
Gatherings and rallies are planned across the United Kingdom from Thursday, when Mr Trump is expected to touch down in Britain. Trump is scheduled to meet with British Prime Minister Theresa May and Queen Elizabeth II later this month.

Ronaldo to Juventus: Real Madrid's leading scorer explains need for 'new cycle'
Real Madrid have sold Cristiano Ronaldo to Juventus in a sensational deal worth £105million. Ronaldo made his debut for Sporting Lisbon when he was 17.

Liu Xia, wife of late China dissident, arrives in Berlin
Friends say Liu Xia had expressed an interest in going to Germany, where she has a network of friends among Chinese dissidents. In a letter published a year ago , Liu wrote she was "going mad" in her isolation, according to the AFP news agency.

Facebook to be fined £500,000 over data breaches
It also said it would send warning letters to 11 political parties to compel them to audit their data protection practices. That's despite earlier estimates that 2.7 million users in the European Union had their data improperly shared.

Prince Louis' christening: Will, Kate, George and Charlotte lead the celebration
Britain's Catherine , Duchess of Cambridge holds Britain's Prince Louis of Cambridge on their arrival for his christening service. In one photo, Prince George and Princess Charlotte can be seen pressing their faces to the window, watching the event unfold.

William, Harry, Kate, & Meghan Are Back Together -- Yaaas
Meghan , 36, and Prince Harry, 33, attended Prince Louis' christening yesterday looking as stylish and loved up as ever. Tourists can follow in Harry and Meghan's footsteps by visiting the GAA museum and taking a stadium tour.

Eden Hazard Makes Big Real Madrid Claim
If Real Madrid do indeed want to sign Hazard , they will certainly have to shell out staggering sums of money to do so. Belgium captain Eden Hazard says that France's Kylian Mbappe is already a serious contender for the Ballon d'Or.

Tropical Storm Chris reaches hurricane strength in Atlantic
With Chris likely to become a hurricane, it would be the second such system during the 2018 Atlantic season. Still, the storm is expected to be upgraded to a hurricane later Tuesday as it moves into warmer waters.

Former Arizona Sen. Jon Kyl to guide Trump's Supreme Court nominee
Reporter: "How many people are you deciding between now?" "I am grateful to you and I am humbled by your confidence in me". All eyes on which senators? "Maybe a handful of Democrats will vote for a Trump pick because they have to politically".

USA to list tariffs on another US$200 billion of Chinese products
The prospective US tariffs would be retaliation against the retaliation. "American families are the ones being punished". He added the USA is ready to target an additional $200 billion, and then $300 billion more should Beijing retaliate.

Prince Harry, Duchess Meghan arrive in Ireland for 1st official foreign trip
Their final engagement in Dublin will be meeting with young people who take part in free coding workshops at Dogpatch Labs. The Duke and Duchess of Sussex began their first official global visit together when they arrived in Ireland on Tuesday.

Supreme jockeying ahead of Donald Trump’s prime-time reveal of court pick
As a result, Trump found more than twice as many judicial vacancies waiting for him when he entered the White House as Obama did. Those views could have implications for independent counsel Robert Mueller's investigation of President Trump.