USA judge allows lawsuits over Monsanto's Roundup to proceed to trial

CC BY 2.0

A judge's ruling means that hundreds of lawsuits alleging Roundup weed killer caused a cancer called non-Hodgkin's lymphoma can move forward.

The decision by U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria in San Francisco followed years of litigation and weeks of hearings about the controversial science surrounding the safety of the chemical glyphosate, the key ingredient in Monsanto's top-selling weed-killer.

Citing expert testimony from three doctors who spoke on plaintiffs' behalf, Chhabria wrote in his ruling, "the opinions of these experts, while shaky, are admissible".

The agrochemical company Monsanto is facing a lawsuit accusing them of having a weed-killing product which causes cancer.

More than 400 lawsuits were filed before Chhabria's court.

Monsanto denies the allegations and in a statement said it would continue to defend the lawsuits with evidence proving there is "absolutely no connection between glyphosate and cancer". "We have sympathy for anyone suffering from cancer, but the science clearly shows that glyphosate was not the cause".


Chhabria said the evidence, "viewed in its totality, seems too equivocal to support any firm conclusion that glyphosate causes" non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.

Johnson, the man involved in the first case to go to trial, used Monsanto Roundup during his job as a pest control manager at a school in the San Francisco Bay Area.

Beate Ritz, an epidemiologist at the University of California, Los Angeles, testified for the plaintiffs that her review of scientific literature led her to conclude that glyphosate and glyphosate-based compounds such as Roundup can cause non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.

The company Monsanto faces 5,000 lawsuits across America as it's alleged that one of their products, Roundup - which is still sold in the United Kingdom - can cause cancer.

But the World Health Organization in 2015 classified glyphosate as "probably carcinogenic to humans". Monsanto has attacked the global research agency's opinion as an outlier. "Here, although there is no need to specify precisely the circumstances under which each plaintiff was exposed to glyphosate, only evidence supporting the conclusion that glyphosate causes National Hockey League in doses within the realistic realm of actual human exposure can get the plaintiffs past summary judgment".

Related News:

  • Isner reaches Wimbledon semi-finals after victory over Raonic

    Isner reaches Wimbledon semi-finals after victory over Raonic

    Nadal, 32, is back in the semi-finals at Wimbledon for the first time since 2011 when he finished runner-up to Djokovic. That inconsistency was eliminated in an absorbing final set before Anderson produced a moment of magic.

    Jeremy Lin Traded To Hawks: Dennis Schroder On The Way Out?

    The Nets also have D'Angelo Russell, the No. 2 pick in the 2015 draft, at the point after acquiring him from the Lakers. Lin has a year left on his contract, and the trade ends his injury-plagued stint in Brooklyn.

    Obama loses more than 2 million Twitter followers amid crackdown

    Twitter said owners of accounts will not be able to log in unless they validate the accounts and reset passwords. Barack Obama's (@barackobama ) total followers shrank by 2.1 million, or 2.1%, to 101.5 million.
  • Xherdan Shaqiri Set For Liverpool Medical As Deal Agreed With Stoke City

    The winger impressed for Switzerland at the 2018 World Cup, including scoring the victor against Serbia in the group stage.
    North Atlantic Treaty Organisation  summit: Trump hails alliance spending promises after crisis meeting

    North Atlantic Treaty Organisation summit: Trump hails alliance spending promises after crisis meeting

    Macron also said that Trump "never at any moment, either in public or in private, threatened to withdraw from NATO". He added: "If they do that, then their trade deal with the U.S. will probably not be made".
    An Unsettled Britain Plays Host to Trump

    An Unsettled Britain Plays Host to Trump

    Trump fans have slammed the blimp, calling it offensive and blasting authorities for allowing it to fly. Trump said he would try to avoid the crowd in the capital during his four-day visit to the country.
  • China says 'bully' United States started a trade war

    China says 'bully' United States started a trade war

    Its trade surplus with the United States over the same period was $133.76bn, up from $117.51bn a year ago . China said the two sides were not discussing restarting trade negotiations.
    Twitter Bigwigs Who Suffered Massive Loss of Followers After Cleanup

    Twitter Bigwigs Who Suffered Massive Loss of Followers After Cleanup

    By contrast, former President Barack Obama's count fell by 2.1 million followers, or 2.1 percent, to 101.5 million. It is these accounts which have been lying locked for a while that are now being removed.
    Chelsea fires manager Antonio Conte after 2 years in charge

    Chelsea fires manager Antonio Conte after 2 years in charge

    Chelsea was beaten to the signing of Romelu Lukaku by Manchester United and then Fernando Llorente by Tottenham, for example. Chelsea has fired manager Antonio Conte after a two-year tenure in which he won the English Premier League and FA Cup.
  • Last Alaska Blockbusters set to close, leaving 1 store in US

    Last Alaska Blockbusters set to close, leaving 1 store in US

    One location on DeBarr Road in Anchorage and another store in Fairbank will be closing down on Monday. At the peak of its popularity in 2004, Blockbuster boasted around 84,300 employees around the world.
    Dutchman takes Tour stage - Martin in the bunch

    Dutchman takes Tour stage - Martin in the bunch

    The Dutch rider, 25, was fastest in a competitive final finish , in which the tour's biggest sprinters were all involved. After the relatively flat first nine days, the race will head south and into the Alps and then the Pyrenees Mountains.
    After Blasting UK Over Brexit, Donald Trump Says Relationship Very Strong

    After Blasting UK Over Brexit, Donald Trump Says Relationship Very Strong

    Trump conflated immigration and terrorism in the interview, and he said that Khan, London's mayor, had done a "terrible job". The president claimed Europe is "losing its culture" because of immigration from the Middle East and Africa.


Most liked

Liverpool sign Xherdan Shaqiri for £13m on five-year deal from Stoke
Speaking after the announcement of the signing, Klopp described the move for the winger as a "no-brainer" for Liverpool . The Swiss global winger is the Reds' third major purchase of the summer, and has penned a five-year deal at Anfield.

Trump rattles North Atlantic Treaty Organisation , knocking its value and assailing Germany
FORDHAM: Everyone that I spoke to was very keen to downplay any concerns, completely understandably. Italian Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte said he had made no decision to increase defense spending.

Kreidler: Trump action signals continuing moves to harm individual health insurance
But in January, in a separate case, a federal district judge in MA upheld the government formula used to calculate the payments. Three programs in The Affordable Care Act endeavored at minimizing the risk to the insurers as they explored the risky markets.

‘Downton Abbey’ Movie Gets Go-Ahead, With Series Cast Returning
Added Focus Features , "Since the series ended, fans of Downton have always been waiting for the Crawley family's next chapter". With 69 nominations, it was the most nominated non-U.S. television show in the history of the Emmys.

Major League Baseball suspends Papa John's promotion until after All-Star break, pizza company says
Papa John's International Inc. began operations in 1984 and had more than 5,200 locations globally. During the call, he reportedly said "Colonel Sanders called blacks n--" and never faced backlash.

Black Widow Solo Film Finds Its Director
Shortland's past credits include " Lore " and "The Berlin Syndrome ", both of which featured female leads. Marvel Studios' Black Widow movie is one step closer to happening, as the film has now set a director.

Man discovers wife, her mechanic lover dead following sex, reports say
- A married woman and her mechanic lover reportedly died from apparent carbon monoxide poisoning in a running auto in a garage. The sources allege Hargrave was paying for the work on her vehicle by having sex with the mechanic, according to WNBC.

Solar eclipse on July 13: How to watch, timings, etc
Speaking to his more than 250,000 followers Mr Begley said: "Coming up this Friday the 13th will be a partial solar eclipse ". Sky gazers are all set to witness the second eclipse of the season - a partial solar eclipse today.

Isaiah Thomas Agrees To One-Year Minimum Deal With Nuggets
The Kings selected Thomas in the second round (60th overall) in the 2011 draft out of the University of Washington. In 17 games, including just one start, for Los Angeles, Thomas averaged 15.6 points and five assists.

Massive sarcophagus found in Egypt - and archaeologists don’t know what lies inside
The existence of the alabaster head may be an indication that burial belonged to some great man of the time. An alabaster head of a man was also found, most likely belonging to the owner of the tomb.

CDC warning on Kellogg's Honey Smacks: "Do not eat this cereal"
People infected with salmonella bacteria can show symptoms after just 12 hours, including diarrhea, fever and abdominal cramps. Pennsylvania (8), MA (7), and California (6) have the most cases, but illnesses are widespread and affecting all ages.

Israeli company plans lunar landing next year
The unmanned mission is a joint effort between private company Israel Aerospace Industries and nonprofit organization SpaceIL . Israel is expected to make a historic Moon landing early next year with a Moon lander that is set to be launched late 2018.

Five things to know about the Ontario government's throne speech
We are striking the cap-and-trade carbon tax from the books. "He shouldn't be ending cap and trade ", he said. Interim Liberal leader John Fraser was critical of the Tory's plan to eliminate the cap-and-trade system.

UAE recalls some hypertension medicines over cancer fears
Drugs containing valsartan are used to treat patients with high blood pressure to help prevent heart attacks and stroke. You should not stop taking your valsartan medicine unless you have been told to do so by your doctor or pharmacist.

Rain begins on southcoast as Chris barrels towards Newfoundland
Other than some rough seas along the East Coast, it poses no threat to the US , the National Hurricane Center said . Chris has become the second hurricane of the 2018 season, but it will continue to pull moisture away from Florida.